Baseball umpires do not make sense, especially now, in the AI era. Every season that passes makes this more clear, and every season no one does anything about it.
The current reality is:
Umpires blatantly miss calls all the time.
Some even have a reputation for it.
When this happens... there is no recourse. The decision is final.
Why are these calls decisive and final! We have multiple camera angles and slow motion in stunning 4k. On video review nearly every bad call can be definitively corrected with this technology. The MLB knows this, and the telecasts dissect these calls in seconds, in real time! Meanwhile, the MLB is content to let mistakes happen, and do nothing to correct them.
It gets worse! The coach or a player must voice their disagreement with these calls, they have no other choice. It's their job, these are athletes, they must have that competitive fire. And when they do, in most cases, the umpire will eject them! Which means, the umpire makes the mistake, and then punishes the player? Are we just paying to watch millionaires get gaslighted on TV? That's baseball now apparently, that's the real game.
Baseball umpires are the closest thing we have to politicians outside of Washington in many ways.
They are inherently flawed
They cannot be challenged
Once they're in, it is near impossible to get them out
They get paid a lot of money to be bad at their job
Everyone knows its a problem, and just ignores it
Now, just recently, in 2025 spring training, the MLB tested an automated ball-strike system. Ultimately, they used it to supplement the umps in place. A batter could challenge a call, and if it was a confirmed bad call, it was reversed and they kept the challenge. Only two challenges per team. This is fine, but here's the thing. We're ceding authority to the tracking system to make the call. This being the case, it's clear. Umps no longer need to bother calling pitches.
I think it’s time to move on from umpires, nothing ruins a sport more than knowing that incompetence played a bigger role in the game than the players.
via Umpire Auditor - X